Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

Two weeks until the Draft. Are the Giants Ready?

I have always observed that the Giants make every effort to eliminate the "need" picks leading up to the draft. Put in its simplest terms, the Giants fill all the holes and acquire the necessary players such that if the draft were somehow cancelled, they could field a team for the season.

Needs after the 2016 season
After the 2016 Season
 - DE could be an immediate need if JPP went elsewhere in free agency
 - DT Hankins is a free agent and figures to get an offer that is more than what the Giants would want to match
 - WR position has depth on top of depth, with 4 veteran starters, and two other s who saw significant playing time
 - Additions at the OT position appeared to be necessary, even if Bowie returned from injury. There wasn't enough depth and all positions could be upgraded
 - Starters at CB were in place but backups were allowed to roll the dice in free agency
 - The only TEs on the roster were Matt LaCosse and Jerrell Adams, both returning from injury
 - Will Johnson is at Fullback, but it was unclear if one was needed or desired
 - Vereen, Jennings, and Perkins still in place with Darkwa a Free Agent. All set there if everyone returns
 - Jerry was a Free Agent, and Pugh was entering his final year of his deal but adding depth there was an option
 - C looked okay with Richburg and Jones as a backup
 - Eli was the QB but there were no backups signed
 - LBs looked set, but there were some guys whose play far underperformed their pay, and the one guy that exceeded his (Keenan Robinson) was a free agent
 - Safety, could the Giants actually be loaded at safety? Collins starts and Andrew Adams will probably enter camp as the other starter. The Thompson Twins return from IR, and Ryan Murphy and Nat Berhe are still on the roster
 - Gould would need to be re-signed at Kicker
 - Brad Wing seemed certain to be the Punter in 2017

Read more: Two weeks until the Draft. Are the Giants Ready?

Which positions should the Giants draft?

I have been working out who might be available where and how they fit into the Giants scheme:


Quarterback-  Eli Manning is 36 years old and the team has started discussing finding his successor.   Eli had a down year last season, but a good deal of his issues could be attributed to a weak offensive line, a lack of a proper running game and a stable of relatively short WRs.   The team seems to have fixed some of the issues.   The team could seriously consider someone like Mahomes in round one (assuming he lasts and there isn't an early QB frenzy).  The team really doesn't have the juice to move up significantly should there be a run (their 3 round pick would only buy them 4 spots).  They could "settle" on lower round QBs.   Jaws thinks that Pitt's Nathan Peterman would be a good fit for the Giants and should be available in the 3rd round.  There is also Miami's Brad Kaaya who should be around rnds 4 or 5 and while I was less than impressed does have good traits for Ben's offense.   If things don't work out in terms of the way the draft plays out, I see the team staying pat as Geno Smith gives them some flexibility.

Wide Receiver-  I would be shocked if the team drafts one as they are pretty settled at this position with the signing of Marshall

Read more: Which positions should the Giants draft?

An Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

I found this outsider's take from Fantasy Alarm rather interesting even if I don't agree:

Despite finishing 11-5 last season, the Giants have some serious issues throughout their roster. They basically got by with unconscious play from their high-priced defense and one-to-two game breaking plays per game from Odell Beckham Jr. While impressive is an understatement for their 2016 accomplishments considering what they were working with, you can’t with a straight face argue that this is a repeatable recipe for success going forward. Serious changes are needed throughout this Giants roster…

First here are some of the reasons I think that this author could be right:

1)  The Giants had a relatively easy schedule in terms of how the schedule fell when the Bye was and the strength of the teams played.  Not sure this can be repeated

Read more: An Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree
  •  Start 
  •  Prev 
  •  1  2  3  4  5 
  •  Next 
  •  End 

Page 1 of 5

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

A  while back someone, I think one of the newer guys, linked to a site that had a draft board in pro style layout.  The rows going down were rounds, and the columns going across were by position.  There were separate boards for offense and defense.I s...
If Davis goes before the Giants pick, does that mean Reuben Foster falls to them?The numbers don't seem to add up. There are at least 19 guys who are supposed to be locks to go top-20.QB - Trubinsky RB - Fournette, McCaffreyWR - Ross, Williams, Dav...
Great work as always!  Thanks so much!Sent from my LG-H872 using Tapatalk
Quote from: Philosophers on Today at 09:07:42 AMSay we take Bolles in round 1, then come right back and drafted someone like Dion Dawkins in round 2.  How would folks feel?  Frankly, I'd be pleased as we need more than ...

Inside Football News

Let’s do a little number crunching and break down what...
Let’s take a final temperature check before the NFL draft....
The eye test last season was bad enough, but the...

Star-Ledger Giants

From Leonard Fournette to Deshaun Watson, Marshon Lattimore to Malik Hooker, here are the best players available in the 2017 NFL Draft at each position.
The 2017 NFL Draft is just days away. Buckle up for a slew of rumors, news, updates, reports, mock drafts and a roundup of which prospects are rising and falling in the most up-to-date projections. What will the Cleveland Browns do with the No. 1 overall selection? Where will North Carolina's Mitchell Trubisky go? Are the Jets in the market for a quarterback with the No. 6 overall pick? Are the Eagles setting their sights on Stanford do-it-all star Christian McCaffrey? Could the Giants trade up from No. 23 to land an impact player?

Big Blue View

Football Outsiders predicts sack totals for the 2017 edge rusher class. Will one be a Giant? As the 2017 NFL Draft, and the New York Giants’ selection at 23rd overall, draws closer, there has been plenty of speculation about who could be the newest Giant by the end of the first round. If you have been following Jesse Bartolis’ “dark horses” series — a series, by the by, that predicted Odell Beckham Jr. — you’ve read about linebackers T.J. Watt of Wisconsin [Full Article] and Tyus Bowser of Houston [Full Article]. Jesse considers these players “dark horses” because they...
Christian McCaffrey is an offensive weapon. Will the Giants get to pair him with Odell Beckham? The New York GIants need more offensive production. They need it from their receiving corps and they need more production from their backfield. Since parting ways with Rashad Jennings, it has become increasingly likely that the Giants will dip into the this year’s incredibly deep and talented running back class. And while most are focusing on bigger, more powerful running backs to complement Paul Perkins, the Giants could well fall in love with Stanford’s Christian McCaffrey. Measurables Pros Incredible movement skills. Probably the...
Go to top